How the top 5 travel management systems rate on sustainability

Sustainability features they offer:

• Emissions dashboard and reporting
  While this is not really a stand out feature in today’s competitive carbon accounting market, having an emissions dashboard is a helpful way to get an assessment of your business travel emissions, which are then organized by department or travel type. It tracks things like air travel and hotel stays, giving an overall picture of your business travel emissions.
  
  
• Sustainable booking prompts
  Navan has introduced a feature called “Train vs Plane” which gives you an emissions estimate for the type of transport you’ve chosen, and encourages you (where possible) to take the train instead of a plane. This way of “gamifying” the booking flow is helpful to educate employees on their emissions totals and encourages compliance with a corporate sustainable travel policy.
  
  
• Carbon emissions budget
  Setting a carbon emissions budget, or “internal price of carbon” (based on either how much you’ve traveled as a business in the past, or by using Navan or industry benchmarks), allows you to assign your own budget to spend on carbon offsetting or reduction projects. This does help increase accountability, but you will still need to find and fund these initiatives yourself, so its not a one-stop solution. 

Sustainability features they offer:

• Optional carbon offsetting 
  GreenPerk charges a €10 fee for every tonne of CO2 (or 1% of the total booking amount) to offset your business travel emissions, including flights, hotels, trains and cars, through a portfolio of climate projects. If we take a 5 night trip from London Heathrow to New York’s JFK (flying business class), you would emit on average 4.5 tons of CO2, so you would pay around €45 on top of your business travel costs to offset that amount. 
  
  
• Emissions dashboard and reporting
  In the reporting tab of TravelPerk, you can get an overview of your emissions by the type of transport and route you’ve taken - this is not exclusive to GreenPerk as TravelPerk clients can see this as well. The data is downloadable as a “GreenPerk carbon footprint report”. As with Navan, an emissions dashboard is a great way of analyzing your business travel emissions, but most travel management systems offer this now, so it's not a stand out feature. 
  
  
• Certificate to show offsets
  TravelPerk’s customers get a certificate / badge to show that they’ve participated in a carbon offsetting scheme which is great, but there’s a downside - customers don't receive any third party tracking links or proof that their emissions have been offset in their company’s name. And the certificate you get from GreenPerk is not official, so you may lack credibility if you need it for your investor or climate reports.

Conclusion

GreenPerk is doing more than just calculating business travel emissions which makes them a competitive choice, but their portfolio of offsetting projects varies in quality. Added to that, the customer still needs to pay to contribute to these projects, which may not be the best nor most transparent financial investment if there is little visibility as to where the money ends up. GreenPerk do have Verra registered projects (the leading standard for climate projects), but some of these are Redd+ projects, which is a forest related offset called “avoidance” / “avoided reforestation”, which have come under heavy criticism for their efficacy. It's therefore worth investigating which offsets your business will be contributing to if you go with GreenPerk.

Sustainability features they offer:

• Optional carbon emissions budgets 
  Just like Navan, Amex GBT Egencia has a feature where you can assign a “fixed price of carbon”, which means a set amount of money that you will contribute to reducing or offsetting your emissions with every tonne of CO2 that you emit. You still get a say in where the money goes though. Amex GBT Egencia puts the emissions budget towards a sustainability project of your choice, effectively acting as a middleman between your company and the project. These include Climate Neutral Group (CNG), atmosfair and Climate Partner.
  
  
• Sustainable booking prompts 
  Egencia has a feature that allows you to “add restrictions to your business travel policy”, essentially acting as a sustainability enforcer to your corporate travel policy. One way this differs from the others is that it allows you to compare flights to train routes in Norway, Spain, Sweden Belgium, France, UK, and the US.
  
  
• “Analytics Studio”
  As part of their broader analytics studio, their offset calculator allows you to track your carbon footprint across your business travel. This feature gives businesses an assessment of their carbon emissions by department and type of travel. 

Conclusion

Amex GBT Egencia are first and foremost a business travel management and expense solution, and while they do well at helping business travelers make more sustainable decisions when they travel for work, customers still need to pay additional fees to offset their emissions which then just go to one of their third party suppliers. So when it comes to sustainability, it's not a seamless or transparent operation.

Sustainability features they offer:

• Sustainability prompts
  Business travel managers have the option to integrate their own sustainable travel policy into the booking features, so that employees are both aware of their footprint when they’re traveling, but also can opt for greener, more sustainable travel options if the company has set these guidelines up. 
  
  
• Carbon reporting
  SAP Concur allows you to track your emissions by giving you an overview of your travel activity by segment, department, route, country and type of travel (e.g short haul or long haul) in a dashboard. As with Navan and GreenPerk, having the option to report on your travel emissions is a great start, but most travel management companies offer this now. 
  
  
• Optional carbon emissions budgets 
  Like Navan, SAP Concur gives businesses the option to set a “carbon offset donation” amount into their travel budget which is then used to fund NGOs and local green energy initiatives through Jet Set Offset. This is a great initiative, but you'll still need to allocate a budget to fund the initiatives yourself, and the projects on offer are not "additional".

Conclusion

SAP Concur offer all the emissions tracking features that you could now expect from a business travel management system, so they don't stand out from Navan, Amex GBT Egencia or GreenPerk. While the projects listed on the Jet Set Offset will certainly have a local impact, their carbon offset donation scheme is not a standout feature because the projects on offer are not "additional". 

Emissions tracking for more than just flights

Most travel management systems just track flights and hotels, but there are a lot of emissions that fall through the cracks, such as metro and taxi rides. Goodwings looks at every single part of the journey so nothing falls through the cracks, and you get the full picture of how much you're emitting from start to finish. 

Full and credible documentation

Reducing and offsetting emissions is good, but if it can't be backed up by the right documentation, it doesn't pass the test. With Goodwings' option to offset and reduce your travel emissions, you'll get a full paper trail with third party links to verify that your emissions have been offset and reduced to the highest standards.